“I was just leaving to me,” he added quietly. “Don’t come looking for me again, Raven. It’s over. Let both of us move on.” As he walked toward the door, I called after him. “So that’s it. Four years ends like this.” He paused, turned slightly. No, it ended 2 months ago. This is just you refusing to accept it. 6 months after Nicholas disappeared from my life, I sat in my new apartment, smaller and in a less desirable neighborhood than the one we’d shared.
I’d kept my job barely, though the promotion I’d been in line for went to someone else, Julian. Ironically, he avoided eye contact in the hallways now. Some friends had tentatively reconnected after my public pursuit of Nicholas stopped, though our relationships remained strained. “You seem better,” my sister said over coffee that morning, though her eyes held a question. “I am,” I replied automatically. The lie came easily after so many months of practice. “Work’s going well. I’m thinking of taking a vacation next month.” “Good,” she hesitated.
“Then, have you heard about Nicholas?” My heart stuttered painfully. “Should I have? He’s engaged to Olivia, the woman he’s been seeing. It was on Instagram last night. The coffee turned to acid in my stomach. 6 months. 6 months from discovering my affair to proposing to someone new. The cosmic unfairness of it burned like bile in my throat. At home, I broke my 6 week streak of not looking him up online. There it was. The announcement, the ring, the glowing comments from friends.
Our friends congratulating him on finding someone who deserves you. celebrating their perfect match. One comment from Tasha stuck out painfully. So happy you found your person after everything. You deserve this happiness more than anyone. I scrolled through photos of them together, hiking at parties, cooking in what must be his kitchen. She fit seamlessly into the life that was supposed to be mine. In each picture, Nicholas looked relaxed, genuinely happy in a way I couldn’t remember seeing in our later years together.
The most painful realization wasn’t that he’d moved on. It was that he seemed better off without me, happier, more himself. While I was still stuck in the wreckage of what we’d been, he’d somehow emerge stronger, finding someone who apparently made him happier than I ever had. My phone pinged with a notification, a group message from Ila to several old friends, including me, probably by accident. She was organizing Nicholas and Olivia’s engagement party. The message included details of the venue, an upscale rooftop bar downtown.
Three glasses of wine later, the idea had metamorphosed from unthinkable to inevitable. I would go, not to cause a scene. I told myself I was past that stage of grief, just to see them together with my own eyes, to understand what she had that I didn’t. To get the closure Nicholas had denied me by disappearing. The night of the party, I spent hours getting ready. New dress, professional makeup, hairstyled perfectly. I arrived fashionably late, riding the elevator to the rooftop with hammering heart.
The hostess smiled as I approached the private section reserved for the party. Name: Raven Mitchell, I said confidently. I’m with the engagement celebration. She checked her tablet, smile faltering. I’m sorry, I don’t see your name on the list. Raven, what are you doing here? I turned to find Ila staring at me, champagne glass in hand. Confusion giving way to alarm. I got the invitation, I said, gesturing vaguely at my phone. The group message. Her face fell. That was sent to you by mistake.
You know you’re not supposed to be here. More heads were turning now. And then through the crowd, I saw him. Nicholas, handsome in a navy suit, arm around a woman in a white dress who had to be Olivia. Our eyes met across the rooftop. His smile vanished. His body tensed slightly, instinctively, pulling Olivia closer to his side, a protective gesture that spoke volumes about how he now saw me as a threat. The hostess was speaking into her earpiece now.
“Security to the rooftop, please.” “Raven, you need to leave,” Ila said, gently but firmly taking my arm. “This isn’t about you. It hasn’t been about you for a long time.” Security arrived. Two men in dark suits with discrete earpieces. “Ma’am, we need you to come with us. I’m leaving, I said, snatching my purse. Tell Nicholas congratulations from me. Tell him I hope she makes him happier than I apparently did. And tell him that real love doesn’t just disappear overnight, no matter what pretty replacement you find.
As security escorted me to the elevator, I caught one last glimpse of the party. Nicholas was speaking urgently to Olivia, who looked concerned but not angry. Their friends had gathered protectively around them, shielding the happy couple from the crazy ex’s intrusion. In that moment, the truth I’d been avoiding for months finally crystallized. I was the villain in their story, the obstacle they’d overcome, the cautionary tale they’d tell at dinner parties years from now. My phone buzzed in my purse, probably my sister, who’d be hearing about this disaster within minutes from someone at the party.
I ignored it, hailing a cab instead. I couldn’t face anyone right now. Not even the one person who still tried to love me through my worst moments. Eventually, I checked my phone. Three missed calls from my sister. Two texts from her. Please tell me you didn’t go to that party. Followed by call me ASAP. A message from an unknown number. This is Olivia. We need to talk. My heart stopped. Olivia, Nicholas’s fianceé had my number. My thumbs hovered over the screen, mind racing.
I finally typed when and where. The response came quickly. Tomorrow, 2 p.m. Riverfront Coffee on Maine. I slept poorly, imagining every possible scenario for this meeting. The next day, I arrived at the coffee shop 20 minutes early, choosing a corner table with a view of the door. At exactly 2, she walked in. I recognized her immediately from the photos, though she looked different in person, taller than I’d imagined, with a quiet confidence in the way she carried herself.
No visible engagement ring. She’d tucked it away, I realized, for this meeting. Raven, she said, sitting down across from me. Thank you for coming. Did Nicholas send you? I asked immediately. No, she wrapped her hands around her mug. He doesn’t know I’m here, and I’d prefer to keep it that way. Then why? I wanted to see you for myself, she said simply. To understand. Understand what? The woman who haunts him. Her bluntness caught me off guard. Even after everything, even with us engaged, there’s this shadow.
I can feel it sometimes when certain songs play. When we drive past your old neighborhood, something like triumph flickered in my chest. So, I wasn’t completely erased after all. I still existed somewhere in his mind. Can I ask you something? She leaned forward slightly. Why did you cheat on him? The directness of the question stunned me. No one had asked it so plainly. I It’s complicated, I stammered. I’m sure it is, she agreed. Most important things are.
We grew apart, I said finally, falling back on the easiest explanation. He was working all the time. I felt neglected. It just happened. She nodded considering this. And was it worth it, the affair? Obviously not, I snapped. Look at my life now. That’s not what I asked, she said gently. I mean, in the moment when you were deciding to cross that line. Did you think it would be worth whatever consequences might come? I didn’t think there would be consequences, I admitted in a small voice.
I never thought he’d find out. And if he did, I trailed off, realizing how selfish it sounded. You thought he’d forgive you? She finished for me. Fight for you, not walk away. I nodded, throat tight. That’s what I needed to understand, she said almost to herself. You never really knew him at all, did you? The words struck like a physical blow. I was with him for 4 years. Of course, I knew him. The Nicholas Ferno would never stay with someone who betrayed him, she said with quiet certainty.
Leave a Comment